New: The Offer Method, version 1 · One payment of US$149 · Every future update free

Offer Method v1 · Lifetime updates free

Would anyone actually pay for my skill?

Look for money already moving to solve the problem your work solves. A friend’s “I’d buy that” and likes on a post count for little, however many you have.

By Luyanda

One version of this question is already settled. Has anyone paid for your skill? Yes: an employer pays for it every month, or a client hired you once, then hired you again. So the skill has a price. Someone else set it, and it sits inside someone else’s business.

The version in the title is the open one: would a stranger pay, under your own name, with no employer in between? It’s tempting to answer it with whatever evidence is nearest. A former colleague says they’d hire you. A friend who runs a small agency hears what you do and says, “I’d buy that.” A post about how you rebuilt your team’s reporting gets more likes than anything you’ve posted before. Each of those sounds like a yes. Each comes from the bottom end of a scale that ranks evidence by how much it can tell you.

That scale is the evidence ladder. It comes from a book I sell on this site. This essay teaches the idea in full, and the book, with its first step, is at the end of the page.

What it means to validate a business idea built on a skill

Much of the advice on how to validate a business idea starts with the idea: a product or an app, waiting to be tested on a market. When the idea is a skill someone already pays you for, what you have is work you’ve done and the people you did it for. So the useful question is about the work. The book asks it this way: what problem does this work solve that someone already pays to have solved?

Look at what that does to “would anyone pay?” It moves the question off you and onto a problem, and onto money already moving toward it. Whether a stranger would choose you is a forecast. Whether strangers are paying someone to make a particular problem go away is something happening now, where you can go and look.

The book is careful with the word validated. It uses it only “in the one sense that word deserves here: built on evidence you gathered and graded, of what your buyers already pay for and complain about.” Two verbs carry that sentence. Gathered means you went and looked. Graded means you decided what each piece of evidence is worth, and the grading has a scale.

The evidence ladder, from strongest to weakest

The book ranks evidence on five rungs. Below is its list, in its order and its words, with two skills run down it to show what each rung looks like at work. Say your skill is getting a finance team’s month-end close to finish on time. Or say it’s running the usability tests that tell a product team what to fix first.

  • Money. Someone is paying for a solution to this now: a posted rate, a job or contract brief, a product people have bought and reviewed. For the close, that’s a contract brief from a growing company that wants its close rebuilt before its first audit. For the tests, it’s independent researchers with a fixed price for a round of testing on their own page.

  • Effort. Time or effort is being spent on it: workarounds, homemade spreadsheets and checklists, someone hired internally to deal with it, long how-do-I threads. For the close: a homemade checklist that gets passed from one finance lead to another, copied and adapted each time. For the tests: a product manager running sessions with a borrowed script, because nobody else owns the job.

  • Pain. The problem is being described, in the sufferer’s own words: complaints, frustrated reviews, exasperated posts. For the close: founders posting that they still can’t see last month’s numbers. For the tests: one-star reviews calling an app impossible to use, from people who gave up on it in the first week.

  • Interest. Someone says they’d want a solution: “I’d love something that…”, survey answers. For the close: a former colleague, now at a bigger company, who says they’d love a checklist like yours if you ever made one. For the tests: a survey where most respondents tick “yes, I’d pay for this”. Interest can use the word pay and still be interest: it’s a sentence about the future, and saying it costs nothing.

  • Attention. Likes, views, follows. For the close: a post about your checklist, liked and shared by people you’ve never met. For the tests: new followers after you shared one finding from a round of testing.

Read the list from the bottom up and one thing grows at every rung: what the evidence cost the person who gave it. A like costs a tap. Interest costs a sentence, and pain a paragraph written in frustration. Effort costs hours of someone’s working week, and sometimes the cost of a hire. Money is a decision already made. The more a signal cost to give, the more it can tell you about whether anyone will pay.

Pain is not payment: the machine’s own wrong answer

Of the five rungs, pain is the one that looks most like money. It’s plentiful and specific. It’s written in the words of the person who has the problem, so it reads like demand. A long thread of people describing the same frustration can look a great deal like a queue of buyers.

The book shows this happening to its own machine. Its worked example follows someone whose skill is getting new people productive fast. The machine’s first read on that skill was a market in new-hire engagement and culture, and it filed the read as something to be tested. Here is the test, from the file it wrote:

WHAT

First read (to be tested): new-hire engagement and culture at
  growing companies.
Test of the first read: highest rung reached is pain. Many founder
  posts about new hires who "never really settle in". Almost nobody
  paying: no contract briefs, no priced services, no roles aimed at
  companies of this size.
  FLAGGED: plenty of pain, nobody paying. Searched for money instead.

From the book’s chapter A1: the machine catching its own wrong answer. The example is onboarding. Yours is whatever someone has paid you for. The people in it are imagined. The method is real.

Read the line that starts Test of the first read. It names the highest rung the evidence reached, and the rung is pain: third of five, below both of the rungs that decide whether to build. The pain was real. The book says so plainly, then gives its verdict in four words: “pain is not payment.”

What happened after that is the part the crop leaves out. For the first read, the search for money found almost none. So the search turned toward money itself, and found it close by: contract briefs from small companies asking someone to build their onboarding before a wave of new starters, and independent consultants selling onboarding packages with a fixed price on the page. The answer moved to the thing people were already paying for.

That’s an awkward thing for a book to print about the tool it sells: the machine got it wrong first, on the page meant to show what it does. The book calls the catch “the most important idea in this book”, and the reason it gives is practical. The ladder is why “the machine’s output is something you check rather than something you trust.” Each finding in the file carries its link and the rung it reached, so you can open the source and judge it yourself.

Decide from the top, write from the middle

The ladder comes with a rule, and the book sets it in bold: “The rule: decide from the top of the ladder, and write your copy from the middle. Money and effort tell you whether to build. Pain tells you what to say when you do.”

The second half of that rule rescues the rung that fooled the machine in the example. Pain is a weak reason to build and a rich source of words, because it arrives in the sufferer’s own language, in the terms they’d use to ask for help. Once the top of the ladder has shown you money moving, the middle shows you how to describe the offer so the person paying sees their own problem in it. A founder who writes that new hires “never really settle in” is no evidence that anyone pays. That phrase might still be the first line of your page.

Interest and attention have no part in that rule, and the book is blunt about it: “Interest and attention, on their own, never justify an offer, however much of them there is.”

That last clause matters most, because attention is the one rung you can see without looking. It’s counted for you, under every post. Money takes a search: briefs, rates and priced services don’t arrive as notifications, and no feed counts them for you. So an idea can collect a great deal of the weakest evidence before anyone has gone looking for the strongest. Deciding from the top means doing the slower search first, the one that’s tempting to skip. An offer built that way starts from what people already pay for, and you can point to where you found it.

Reading a rung honestly

Putting evidence on the right rung is half the job. The other half is being honest about how much of it you have, and the book gives two checks for that.

The first is “Two echoes are one voice.“ “Two posts quoting the same article are one piece of evidence, not two.” Ten posts saying a problem is growing can all trace back to one report. Ten glowing reviews can be one seller’s clients. So for every finding that matters, the book says, “ask where it came from, and whether anyone else reached the same thing independently.” The file in the book’s example does exactly this: two of its posts “quote the same article, so they count once.”

The second is “Sample both sides of the room.“ “Every venue leans one way. Complaint threads and one-star reviews lean toward what’s wrong. Testimonial pages and ad libraries lean toward what’s promised.” Read only the complaints and every problem looks unsolved; read only the testimonials and every problem looks solved already, and crowded. Either way, the book says, “you end up describing the venue instead of the market.”

Both checks ask the same thing of a finding: count the sources, and know which way each one leans, before you count the mentions.

Which rung?

The ladder outlasts any one offer. In the book’s words, it “keeps working long after this offer is live: on the next offer, the next market, any decision with evidence behind it.” And it does one more job: “It’s also how you check the machine. When a file says “strong demand”, the ladder asks: which rung?”

That question works on any claim about a market, whoever makes it: a colleague, a forecast, an AI chat, this essay. How much of that evidence is enough before you decide is a separate question, with its own essay: how much research is enough before you start.

Turned on your own skill, the ladder makes the title’s question one you can go and check. Would anyone pay becomes: is anyone paying, now, to solve the problem my work solves, and where would I see it?

This book can’t promise you a client, a sale or an income. Whether anyone says yes is a stranger’s decision, and nobody can sell you a stranger’s decision.

You have a skill someone has already paid for. This is a book and a team of AI agents that take you, on evidence you can check, to answering “so what do you do?” with a price in the sentence — and to a live page and messages you’ve already sent. Run its first step on your own work, free, before you buy.

Ask the book’s first question about your work

The prompt below asks an AI for up to three problems your work could solve, and where to look for money already moving. The real test comes in the research chapter.

This takes a few minutes and needs no setup and no paid tool: any AI chat you already use will do, including a free one.

Describe the work in your own words. Don’t paste documents, client names, or anything your employer owns.

Chapter A1 · Your first read

I’m going to describe my work. Using only what I tell you, suggest up
to three problems this work could solve that someone might pay to have
solved.

For each one, give me:
1. The problem in one sentence, in the words of the person who has it.
2. Who has it, described by the situation they’re in, not only by a
   job title.
3. Where I could look to see whether money is already moving to solve
   it: the kinds of job posts, contract briefs, priced services or paid
   products to search for, and the words I’d search with.

These are hypotheses for me to test, not findings. Do not claim any
evidence you haven’t seen. No statistics and no “research shows”. If
you can’t search the web, don’t pretend to. Tell me where to look.

My work:
EITHER My skill is ______. I’ve used it to ______.
OR Three things I’ve built, fixed, written or handed over at work:
        1. ______ (used by ______)
        2. ______ (used by ______)
        3. ______ (used by ______)

Select and copy it into any AI chat, fill in the EITHER line or the OR list, then send. It returns “hypotheses for me to test, not findings.” No email needed.

Free emails: new essays, open questions, what changed

You’d get essays like this one as they’re published, the questions we can’t yet answer, and each version’s note of what changed, sent only when there’s something to report.

Also from the book, taught in full

How much should I charge for my consulting?

There’s no formula that turns your pay into a rate. Price the result the work produces, above a floor only you can set, and say one number with its reason.

How much research is enough before I start?

Research done to reach a decision has a finish line: the moment you can write that decision in one sentence, with your strongest evidence beside it.

Is my field too saturated to start in?

A crowded field usually means people already pay for the work. Where you fit is in what every offer there leaves undone, and buyers’ complaints point to it.