New: The Offer Method, version 1 · One payment of US$149 · Every future update free

Offer Method v1 · Lifetime updates free

Is my field too saturated to start in?

A crowded field usually means people already pay for the work. Where you fit is in what every offer there leaves undone, and buyers’ complaints point to it.

By Luyanda

Look at who already sells what you do, and the list comes back long. Firms with a team for every part of the job. Software with thousands of customers. Freelancers with years of finished work on show. Somewhere on each of their pages is a line saying they do the thing you’re good at.

Set beside that list, an offer you haven’t yet made under your own name looks small, and it’s tempting to put it down before it’s written. You’ve done the work for years, inside someone else’s business, and you know it holds up. The hesitation is narrower than that, and harder. It’s about why anyone would pick you over everyone already on the list.

The market isn’t saturated. You have a positioning problem.

What makes a field look full is sameness: offers written off each other’s pages until they blur into one. That’s a problem with positions, and a position is something you make, so it can be made differently. The skill under it is the one part already settled. So take the crowd apart and look at how the sameness gets made.

The way of taking it apart comes from a book this site sells, from its research and its chapter on positioning. The book itself is at the end of this page, after the idea is done.

Why a crowded field fills up with the same offer

Start with what the crowd tells you, because the first thing it tells you is useful: a crowd of sellers usually means people already pay for this work, and that is the evidence the essay on whether anyone would pay for your skill is built around.

What it doesn’t tell you is why the crowd looks the way it does. Read the pages side by side and a pattern shows. The same promise, in nearly the same words. The same list of what’s included. The same picture of the buyer, drawn wide enough to fit almost anyone with the problem.

The cause is ordinary. A new seller does what looks like homework: reads the pages of the people already selling, notes what they promise, and writes an offer that promises the same, a little better. The next seller reads that page and does the same. Each page is built from the one before it, so each answers the same question the same way, and the question is the seller’s own: what should I say I do.

Copying feels like research because it starts from something real. The pages exist, so somebody presumably buys from them. But a page only records what a seller decided to say. What the seller’s buyers still wish someone would do is somewhere else.

What none of those pages was built from is the buyer’s complaint about everything already on offer. You find that in reviews, in threads, in the replies where a buyer says what the thing they paid for failed to do, and copying a page never takes you there.

Which leaves the one question a crowd like that can’t get past. If a hundred brands run the same playbook, the same positioning, the same mechanics — why would a buyer ever choose yours?

A page built from other pages has no answer to that. Whatever it says, the page beside it says too.

Why the book asks why last

The book’s research runs through five questions in a fixed order, and why would this buyer choose you comes last. Its reason fits in two sentences:

“WHY comes last, because you can only position yourself against the alternatives this buyer actually uses for this problem. Before you know those, positioning is a guess about competitors who might not even be in your buyer’s view.”

That’s the copying pattern, described from the other side. A seller who starts from the other sellers’ pages is answering why-me first, before settling what problem they solve or for whom. The book’s word for what that produces is a slogan.

By the time the book reaches why, the question is narrow: what this particular buyer uses now, for this particular problem. And it insists on two answers that studying the crowd will never turn up: “Always include the two alternatives that never advertise: doing nothing, and doing it themselves.”

For each alternative, it wants what it costs and what’s weak about it for this buyer, “in the buyer’s own complaining words.” Then comes the sentence that undoes the copying pattern: “Read each alternative’s own pages and ads for what it promises, and its reviews and threads for where it falls short.” Sameness is the first half of that sentence, done alone.

Where a real weakness meets a real strength

Here is the rule the book’s positioning turns on, in its own words:

Position where a real weakness meets a real strength. Either one alone isn’t enough: a weakness you can’t fix is someone else’s opportunity, and a strength nobody’s missing is a hobby.

Read it as two warnings, one on each side. A weakness in what buyers use now is open ground only if you can fix it; the ones you can’t are waiting for whoever can. And the thing you do best only counts where a buyer is missing it. Aimed anywhere else, it’s still a hobby, however good the work is.

It’s natural to come at this from the strength side: here is what I’m best at, so where can it go. The book comes at it from the weakness side, for the same reason it asks why last. Start from your strength and you can always find a gap it seems to fit. Start from a complaint buyers already make, and the gap was real before you got there.

The book works this through on one example. The example is onboarding. Yours is whatever someone has paid you for. The book is plain that it’s invented: “The people in it are imagined. The method is real.” The example’s buyer is a small company taking on new people, and each alternative it uses falls short somewhere specific. The software arrives empty. The large consultancy is built for bigger firms, and its proposal alone takes six weeks. The freelancer billing by the hour can’t say what the whole thing will cost. And doing it themselves means the founder runs every induction on a Friday afternoon, which is exactly what the founder is trying to stop doing.

The alternatives change with the field. A finance lead’s buyers might use accounting software, a large firm, or a spreadsheet someone updates on Sunday nights. A data engineer’s might use a dashboard tool, an agency, or nothing at all. Each alternative has its weak spot, and the buyers who live with it tend to say so, in public, in their own words.

None of this needs a name. The book is strict on that point: the comparison stays private, and when a position reaches a page or a message, “it argues against the pattern (‘software that arrives empty’)”. No company appears on anything a buyer sees. This essay has kept to that from its first line, and the argument hasn’t lost anything by it.

Go back to the example and look at what its weaknesses have in common. Each one is a piece of work the alternative won’t do: fill the tool, write the proposal sooner, fix the price, take the job off the founder’s desk. That’s where open ground usually sits, in the work the others leave undone, and it’s the ground the example’s position is built on. I’d go further than the book does here. Your superpower is usually the thing the “experts” tell you not to do.

When the alternatives are bigger than you

The book expects a first-time seller to flinch at this point, and it puts the flinch into words. When the alternatives include a consultancy and a software company, the natural thought is “who am I to stand against them?” The book’s reply is five words long: “Look again at their weaknesses.”

In the example, those weaknesses are about size: built for bigger firms, slow to propose, made for thousands of customers and empty for each one. A large firm can’t fix those without becoming a different firm. So, in the book’s words, “The seller is choosing a place a large firm can’t stand.”

It’s the same rule, read from the small side: the weakness a large firm can’t fix is the opening a smaller seller can stand in.

Size is one half of the hesitation. Proof is the other, and the book meets it under a heading written for this exact position: “Proof, when you haven’t sold this under your own name.” It begins: “That’s the usual starting point, and there’s nothing in it to hide.” Then the instruction: “Your proof is your past work: what you built, fixed or ran, and what changed, described without names or anything an employer owns.”

In practice that’s a plain sentence or two. A finance lead might describe rebuilding how a company closes its books each month, and what changed for the people waiting on the numbers. A data engineer might describe the reports that stopped breaking. No client names, nothing the employer owns, and nothing that needs a logo to be believed.

This site starts there too. The book tells you never to use a testimonial you don’t have. I don’t have any yet, so there are none here.

A method you aim at your own market

For years the digital space has preached one gospel: copy what I do and you’ll get what I get. Use my blueprint. The whole internet is selling you the same blueprint. The flaw is built in: it hands the same instructions to anyone who listens, so the pages it produces come out alike, copies of copies. What it turns out is a minion: one more person running the identical playbook, hoping to make a sale on luck.

If you’ve reached for it, that made sense: it was offered as the way in, and it looked like homework. Your skill was real before any of it, and no playbook can issue it. This page is selling something too, so check it for the same flaw. If the book at the end turns out to be the same gospel in a new cover, close the tab.

What I’d put in its place is a method you aim at your own market, with your own skill as the answer to the problems you find there. It bends to you, because your field is what it studies: your buyer, the alternatives they put up with now, and where those fall short. The book describes its own reach in one line: “It runs from the skill you have to messages sent and answers read.” And when it’s done, it can be run again, “for a second offer or a second market.” Each time, the position comes up from the ground: out of your own buyers’ complaints, read by you.

In the book, this is chapter B3, “Position it against what they’d use instead.” It takes the research you’ve done on your own buyer and turns it into a position, row by row, with your own reason for choosing the problem at its head, so you can say why a buyer would choose you and show what each part of it rests on. It’s real reading and real deciding, about a market you studied yourself.

So the question at the top of this page has an answer. A crowded field usually means the work has buyers, and it says nothing about where you fit. Where you fit is in what the crowd leaves undone, and that only shows once you’ve read what its buyers say about it. Another seller can copy your page in an afternoon. To copy the position under it, they’d have to do the reading you did, and they’d still arrive without your skill.

This book can’t promise you a client, a sale or an income. Whether anyone says yes is a stranger’s decision, and nobody can sell you a stranger’s decision.

You have a skill someone has already paid for. This is a book and a team of AI agents that take you, on evidence you can check, to answering “so what do you do?” with a price in the sentence — and to a live page and messages you’ve already sent. Run its first step on your own work, free, before you buy.

The book’s contents, from the start

The essay above is one idea from the book. Below is the front of the book’s contents; the full list is one click away, and so is the free first step.

The Offer Method · Version 1 · Contents

Before you begin

  • An opening

  • What this is made of

  • What you’ll walk away with

  • What this can’t promise

  • What it’s for

Section A — The machine, and your free will

  • A1. What you’re holding

  • A2. Two roads to the same place

  • A3. Road one: set up the machine

  • A4. Road two: the browser kit

  • A5. Meet your team

  • A6. How to run it and stay in charge

  • A7. The five Ws: find out what your market will pay for

The book’s own contents page, cut after Section A.

Free emails: new essays, open questions, what changed

You’d get essays like this one as they’re published, the questions we can’t yet answer, and each version’s note of what changed, sent only when there’s something to report.

Also from the book, taught in full

How much should I charge for my consulting?

There’s no formula that turns your pay into a rate. Price the result the work produces, above a floor only you can set, and say one number with its reason.

Do I need another course before I start?

Only when a question about your own work needs one. A course or a tool earns its place at that moment, and the question comes first.